Articles › Comparisons

Comparison

Is Apple Dictation good enough, or do you need something else?

For a lot of people, Apple Dictation is enough, and it’s free. If you dictate the occasional email or note, try it properly before you pay for anything. You may never need another app.

We make SpokenKey, a small independent Mac app, so you should know where we’re coming from. We use both SpokenKey and Apple Dictation on our own Macs. This page is about when the built-in option stops being the right one, and when it doesn’t. Everything we say about Apple’s feature comes from Apple’s own support pages, checked in November 2026.

What Apple Dictation does well

It’s built into macOS and costs nothing. You turn it on in System Settings › Keyboard › Dictation, then start it with the Microphone key, a shortcut such as "Press Fn (Function) Key Twice", a custom shortcut, or Edit › Start Dictation in most apps. Escape or the same key stops it.

A few things it does better than SpokenKey, and we’d rather say so up front:

  • Spoken punctuation and formatting commands. You can say "comma", "new paragraph" or "caps on" and it does what you’d expect. SpokenKey has nothing like this.
  • Auto-punctuation in supported languages, so you often don’t have to say the commas at all.
  • No timeout on length. Apple’s own wording is that you can dictate text of any length without a timeout.
  • Language and microphone choices live in the same Keyboard › Dictation settings, so you pick what you want.
  • On-device processing on some setups. The Keyboard settings tell you whether dictation is processed on your device and not sent to Siri servers.

That’s a solid list for zero dollars. If you mostly want to get a few sentences into a text field, stop reading and go use it.

The situations where it falls short

None of these will bother everyone. Each one bothers somebody.

It stops when you stop talking. Apple says dictation stops automatically when no speech is detected for 30 seconds. If you dictate in a steady stream, you’ll never notice. If you think out loud, pause to work out the next sentence, or glance at a document while you talk, you’ll get cut off at the worst moment.

It can’t capture Mac audio. Dictation listens to your microphone. If you want a transcript of a call where you also need the other side, the sound coming out of your Mac isn’t part of what it hears.

There’s no history. Once you’ve dictated something and moved on, there’s no list of what you said earlier. If you lose the text, you lose it.

It may need the internet. Whether your audio stays on the Mac depends on your language and setup. Apple’s privacy page says that when dictation isn’t processed on the device, what you say is sent to Apple, and audio isn’t stored unless you opt in to Improve Siri & Dictation. Apple’s own troubleshooting also says "You may need an internet connection." If you want to know where your audio goes, you have to check your own Keyboard settings. If you’re having trouble getting it to work at all, our guide to Mac dictation not working covers the usual fixes.

What SpokenKey does differently

SpokenKey is a Mac app for Apple silicon (M1 or later) on macOS 15.0 or later. It’s $29, one time, for a perpetual license on one Mac, with no subscription and no account. You paste a license key. There’s no free trial, but there’s a 7-day refund with no questions asked.

Push-to-Talk with Fn. You hold Fn, speak, and let go. While you talk, the partial words stay inside SpokenKey, so the field you’re typing into doesn’t change under you. When you release, SpokenKey finalizes the text on your Mac and inserts it into the focused field, when it can verify that the insertion worked. The menu-bar cue walks through "Recording · Local", "Finalizing…" and "Inserted · Not saved". Then you choose Save to History or Done, and the text isn’t saved unless you choose to.

If it can’t insert, it doesn’t throw the text away. It shows "Your text is ready to copy" with a Copy text button, and you switch back and paste. To work at all, Push-to-Talk needs two permissions, Input Monitoring (to hear the Fn key) and Accessibility (to type into the field). Both are under System Settings › Privacy & Security.

Long-Form for calls and long thinking. You pick Microphone or Microphone + Mac audio, then select Continue. Nothing records until you do. The second option includes sound playing on your Mac, such as the other person on a call, and needs the Screen & System Audio Recording permission. The transcript stays hidden while you record, which is useful if you tend to fiddle with half-finished text. When you want to look, Pause, edit the confirmed text, copy it, then Resume or Stop and finalize.

History. Finished Long-Form transcripts are saved on your Mac. By default they’re kept for 30 days. You can change that to 7 days or No Expiry. Raw-audio history is off by default, and if you turn it on, recordings stay on the Mac for 30 days.

A Whisper model on the Mac. Transcription uses a Whisper model bundled with the app (whisper.cpp, the multilingual base model), so there’s no separate download. Whisper detects the spoken language itself and adds punctuation from context, as Whisper models do. We aren’t going to claim it punctuates better than Apple does, because we don’t have numbers and wouldn’t trust our own impression. Your audio and transcripts aren’t sent to a server. The app goes online only to check your license and for updates, and to send optional crash reports and usage statistics (both off by default) or feedback you choose to send. The privacy policy has the details.

One more honest limit: SpokenKey doesn’t work in every app or field. If it can’t insert, you get the copy fallback described above.

What you give up with SpokenKey

Quite a bit, compared with a free tool that’s been around for years.

  • No spoken punctuation or formatting commands, and no voice commands for editing.
  • No language picker. Whisper detects the language, and you can’t override it.
  • One bundled model. You can’t switch to a larger one.
  • No custom vocabulary or dictionary.
  • No AI rewriting, tone changes or filler-word cleanup.
  • No file import, no speaker labels, no summaries.
  • It costs $29, where Apple Dictation costs nothing.
  • Apple silicon only. If you’re on an Intel Mac, SpokenKey won’t run.

If you rely on saying "new paragraph" and "comma", stay with Apple Dictation. If you need custom vocabulary or a tool that rewrites your text, SpokenKey isn’t it either, and our comparison with Wispr Flow or the wider guide to dictation apps for Mac will point you somewhere better.

Try this before you buy anything

Apple Dictation gets more pleasant with a few minutes of setup.

  1. Open System Settings › Keyboard › Dictation and check the microphone source. If it’s set to a laptop mic in a noisy room, pick a better one.
  2. Set a shortcut you’ll actually press. "Press Fn (Function) Key Twice" works for many people, and you can set a custom shortcut instead.
  3. Check the language, and read the line that says whether dictation is processed on your device.
  4. Learn the three or four spoken commands you’d use daily, such as "comma" and "new paragraph".

Give it a week of real use. If the 30-second cutoff, the missing call audio or the lack of history keeps getting in your way, that’s the point to look at SpokenKey on the download page.

Questions

Is Apple Dictation good enough for most people?

For short notes, messages and the odd email, yes. It’s free, supports spoken punctuation and many languages, and has no length limit.

Does Apple Dictation work offline?

It depends on your language and setup. Check System Settings › Keyboard › Dictation, which shows whether dictation is processed on your device, and note that Apple’s troubleshooting says you may need an internet connection.

Why does Apple Dictation stop on its own?

Apple says it stops automatically when no speech is detected for 30 seconds. Press your shortcut again to restart it.

Can Apple Dictation transcribe a meeting?

It listens to your microphone, so it won’t capture the other side of a call coming out of your Mac. SpokenKey’s Long-Form mode can, using Microphone + Mac audio.

What’s the difference between SpokenKey and a Whisper model on its own?

SpokenKey bundles the multilingual Whisper base model, so there’s nothing extra to download. The app adds Push-to-Talk with Fn, Long-Form recording and a History you control.

Can I get a refund on SpokenKey?

Yes. There’s a 7-day refund, no questions asked. See the refund policy.